BEGINNINGS:
What makes a boy, a young lad, want to 'go for a soldier',
as songs of the day often put it. To understand Harry's
possible reasons, for it's all speculation and no one can
now be entirely sure, we need to understand his time.
He was born a Victorian, in 1893, but grew up an Edwardian.
He would have been aged 8 in 1901 at the time of the old
queen's death and the ushering in of a complete new age, as
well as a new century. What was going on during those
formative years? The immediate and obvious answer is, The
Boer War, taking in those years from when Harry was about 6
to when he was 9 or 10. And before the Boer War, stories
told by old timers of the times of General Gordon, the siege
of Khartoum, and even further back, the Indian Mutiny, were
in abundance for any lad that wanted to listen.
There were all sorts of influences on a boy; other boys, old
soldiers related to or known to the family, and not least a
boy's own parents. It was not common for a mother to
actively encourage soldiering in any lad, though it has to
be said that when that choice was made, a mother would often
be as proud of her son as any father. I've no idea whether
Harry's father, my great-grandfather Charles Holt, had some
or any influence on his son in either direction. But we can
make a pretty shrewd guess as to what Harry's choices were
for future employment, or for any lad in that district at
that time.
To sum up, there were four choices. The easiest and most
obvious, and most commonly taken too, was to be a miner, as
was his father. There were almost a dozen mines within the
immediate Coalville and Whitwick areas, employing thousands
of men. If that was what a boy really wanted, and many did,
he could go 'down pit', like his dad.
I haven't gone deep enough in Charles' story to know whether
he served in the military or not, but we can be sure that
once his son was aged about 10, with the end of schooling
getting ever closer, he would have impressed upon his son
both the benefits and drawbacks of working underground.
Harry would also have seen and heard some of these for
himself, and heard the conversations and been aware of the
week-to-week financial struggles of life down the pit. He
would also have been aware that boys, and girls, as young as
he was then, had been forced to work underground within
living memory, the days of wider use of child labour in all
industries not all that long passed. As to the dangers, they
were ever present in local overheard conversations, not
least the recent Whitwick pit disaster in 1898, a week or
two before Harry's 5th birthday. I feel there would be no
escaping local chat, looks in the street, the general news
and air of grief and despondancy, even for a 5 year-old.
Harry would have known well the dangers of working
underground from a very early age.
To avoid that, there were perhaps three other obvious
choices. First of which was to get a job on the land, a
local farm, and be a farmhand, perhaps with a view to
promotion to a cowhand, pighand or even ploughman. Indeed,
his older brother had done just that at first, but he still
went down the pit when old enough. Poor renumeration as it
was for the danger and the shifts, it was still where the
money was.
Another local choice would be to get a job in one of the
many hosiery, knitwear and sock factories abounding in
Coalville at the time. There were also some shoe factories,
in the main for ladies shoes, but most of the work in all
those places was filled by women. Becoming a mechanic and
maintaining the increasingly complicated factory machinery
would be the best a boy could hope for in that area, one
that needed a decidedly mechanical turn of mind.
A further choice would be to move - to the big town. In
Harry's case, he had a choice of three or four almost
equi-distant, all booming industrial towns of their day.
Both Coventry and Derby were near enough, and Loughborough
had a growing bell foundry and electrical industries. On the
question of factories of all sorts, all were heated by
steam, ie, coal, and all had boilers that required
boilermen, and stokers to feed those boilers. But the most
obvious choice was the county town, just 12 miles away,
Leicester. And many did make that choice. That is exactly
how my paternal family came to leave that same area and move
to that town around about that same time.
The final choice, invidious to a boy's mother, was to go for
a soldier, or even worse, become a Jack Tar and go to sea.
To join 'the forces', albeit there were only two to choose
from. But to a father, already a miner and very conversant
with the dangers therein, soldiering was not such a bad
choice. At least it was out in the open and under the sun,
and one could argue that any dangers were of equal balance,
a simple choice: to be killed underground by being gassed or
a rockfall, or killed above ground by a bullet or bayonet. A
no brainer, we'd say.
TO BE A SOLDIER:
So it was that, in 1911 and as soon as he was 18 and
eligible to serve, Harry joined a local unit of the
Territorial Forces. What later became the Territorial Army,
our TA of late memory, the Territorial Forces were Britain's
army reserve, trained for both local defence as well as with
a view to any necessary foreign service. Most county
regiments had a TF component, one battalion which was
composed of part-time soldiers who lived at home, issued
with hand-me-down and obsolete weapons and kit, and still
had ordinary civilian paid employment.
In Harry's case, that employment would be at the mine. He
would have the best of both worlds, be a miner for as long
as he could stand it, whilst also being a part-time soldier
and retain the option of joining the colours full time. The
1911 census shows him employed as a 'pony driver -
underground', and living at home in Highfield Street. He
worked at South Leicester Pit, which was in fact at
Ellistown and just south of Coalville. His elder brother,
Bill, was listed as an 'ag lab' - ie, working on the land,
on a farm. Being in the TF brought other benefits; free
holidays. Summer camps, military exercises and route marches
may not be regarded as a free holiday now, a miner working
underground - who didn't earn enough to afford going away
for annual holidays - 'going on camp' was literally a breath
of fresh air, plus he went to places he would never have got
to otherwise. And it carried some 'street cred' for any lad
back in the day.
We know nothing more until 1914, in the spring of that year
when he married Violetta Manderfield, a lass from over
Shepshed way, at the little 'tin tabernacle' further down
Highfield Street. Where and how they met, as is often the
case with most of our grandparents, we have no idea.
Shepshed is over 'the forest', halfway over to Loughborough
and outside of the immediate mining areas of Coalville and
Whitwick. Indeed, those two towns are at the northern end of
the coalfield which stretched mostly
southwards
as far as Bagworth and Desford. There were certainly plenty
of pits that Harry could have found work in, perhaps the
nearest not more than a couple of miles away over at
Snibston, a little way down Ashby Road in Coalville itself.
For three years, now Private Holt, 4872, trained in
soldiering on occasional weekends, plus an annual fortnight
compulsory camp somewhere well away from home, with the 5th
Battalion of the Leicestershire Regiment, a Territorial
Forces reserve battalion.
We can assume he learnt how to wear his uniform, march and
drill, do basic ceremonials, as well as learn the rules of
handling rifles and go some way to being as good a marksman
as his eyesight and nerves would allow.
To that end, given his later trade as a Lewis gunner, we
also have to assume there was nothing wrong with his eyes
nor marksmanship. His record shows that, shortly after the
start of his service in the following year, he attended the
summer training camp at Aberystwyth. The date curiously
enough, 4 Aug 1912, exactly two years to the day before
England and her history was to change forever.
Come that fateful day, which we all know the date off by
heart, as well as a good many of the events on that day both
in London and around a feverish nation, we also know that
the actual declaration of war was late that night, at 11pm.
It would be the next day that national headlines would
proclaim on hundreds of placards in one fateful word, "WAR".
The nation became animated almost as one, and thousands of
young men, some much too young, and some older ones too,
flocked to barracks and recruiting centres in every town and
city to sign on into the king's service.
As did Harry, for his service record shows him 'attesting'
into the Leicestershire Regiment on 5 August 1914. He must
surely have been in the mass of men flocking to the colours
and almost crushed in the rush. The nation's anger as well
as disbelief at German affrontery to attack a neutral
country was heightened as news quickly came in of most
definite atrocities, the cruel killing of women and
children.
Of course, we know now that the attack on Belgium was merely
a means to an end; Belgium was not the real target, which
was namely, to attack and invade the French.
But no matter, those early news reports, plastered on
newstands and carried swiftly by rail to the ends of the
country the same day, animated folk to almost hysterical
proportions. We have to remember, there was no radio news, a
national broadcasting service still a long way from being a
reality. The BBC itself was not formed until 1922.
Harry, and his friends, were caught up in all that. By now,
he was aged 20 and newly married. What Violetta thought of
his rush to go to war, we don't know, but she had married a
soldier, and we must assume she was proud of him even if not
fully amenable to the prospect of extended periods of
separation. Also, they had now moved into a home of their
own; well, a rented home of their own.
Just up the street from where he had lived with his parents,
but back towards Coalville, a new terrace of cottages had
been built in 1904, called 'Oak Grove Cottages'. Only 10
years old, they were in terraces of eight, divided by one
covered entry right in the middle. Harry and Violetta now
took possession of the first house on the left hand side of
the entry.
Each house had a water supply - a pump in the kitchen -
mounted on a low-level enamelled sink, though as it
happened, there was a communal well at the back also. Later,
when no longer required and more of a danger than an asset,
grandad would cover that well and build his shed over it.
There was also an outside loo, one to each house, something
else of a luxury at the time. It was a modern 'flush' loo by
the time I knew it, though I suspect it was a lot more basic
than that when those cottages were first built.
The kitchen had a little extension, a cold pantry, with a
tiny window paned, not with glass, but a fine wire mesh. The
place was like a fridge in winter, before fridges were
invented, but still cool in summer - the whole point of it
really. In the corner of the kitchen itself opposite the
sink, a raised brick plinth across the corner, underneath
which a fire could be lit which served to heat up a copper
boiler standing above.
That was in 1914, and believe it or not, that is much how
the arrangement was in 1955 from which my earliest memories
stem. It was where my mum and her three sisters were born
and grew up, and both my grandma and grandad died. A real
family home, with the usual mix of both happy - and tragic -
memories.
Being new, and Highfield Street not having been built up as
continuous housing down both sides, there were as yet no
house numbers. The postman knew everyone, and each house had
a name, or was part of a row that had a name. So it was with
Oak Grove Cottages, and being new and with no number, it led
to some confusion with the military authorities about his
address later. On his records, this is clearly given, and we
that know the area knew what it meant. Later, it would be
allocated a number ... 208.
But that confusion, I believe, may nearly have got him
arrested later when his final call-up came, as his official
letter calling him for a medical in London was addressed to
'Oak Street', and there being no such street in Coalville,
the papers were returned to the War Office. On which point,
minor panic set in with officialdom, with letters too and
fro to trace him that have actually been preserved amongst
his records. The end result was he had much less notice to
'mobilise' than he should have. But that came later. It's a
wonder he didn't find Redcaps come looking for him.
"IT'S WAR" ~ "BRITAIN AT WAR" ~ "FLEET READY"
The German attack on Belgium, abhorrent as it was, had not
exactly come out of the blue. This war had been brewing, and
looming larger for some time, some years in fact, and there
had been plenty of time to prepare. Local history tells us
that on that first full day of the war, 5th August, there
had already been a huge tented encampment of the
Leicestershire Regiment at Whitwick, in the fields below the
woods on Loughborough Road.
It was to here that the youth, and not so youth, of
Coalville and Whitwick headed to enlist in the king's
service, and here too went Harry and his friends. As an
existing member of the regimental reserves, he may well have
not quite expected the knock-back he gained that very day,
purely on account of his job.
For his offer to serve, at least in the short term, was
refused, and he was duly sent back to his work. His
attestation sheet shows his original dates of joining the
TF, in 1911, and then shows his further attestation to join
the regular army as on the 5th August 1914. In effect, he
was told, 'thank you, but not now son, we need you at home
digging coal'. And that would have been a truth he could not
argue with, and no doubt quite a few other young local
colliers had the same result. Also, being a newly married
man may have had something to do with it. I think Violetta
may have been much relieved when he returned home,
chastened, a bit put out by rejection, but safe . . . for
now.
There were lots of reserved occupations, mostly in essential
industries and services, and once a man was designated as
being in such a job, it was almost impossible to
re-designate that job and escape its clutches. For men that
didn't want to fight, or didn't have the required degree of
belligerance and who were just not up to soldiering, a
reserved occupation was verily a godsend.
For those that were keen, did want to go and fight and
serve, it was nothing more than a trap. Coal mining was one
such trap. In the early days of trench warfare, and into
1916, digging under an enemy's trenches became a popular
means of attack, by tunnelling and laying huge explosive
charges to blow whole sections of enemy trenches to kingdom
come. To this end, former miners, and a few brought from the
English and Welsh coalfields, were recruited into the Royal
Engineers for that very purpose. But that came much
later.
For now, for Harry, his consolation was that it was a given
fact that this war would be over by Christmas. The fact was
plastered all over the press. Everyone believed it.
Of course, we know now that the war was not over by
Christmas, or the next Christmas nor the one after that.
1915 came and went, and one defeat or setback followed
another. But Harry had to keep at his underground work.
By early 1916, the war was going very badly and had become
the very static and bogged down trench warfare we now know
so much about. For Harry, nothing much had changed, other
than he was now a father, his first daughter Gladys being
born at the end of the previous October, in 1915. In some
ways, his chances of breaking his mining bonds and getting
away to the war were now just ever so slightly a little more
remote, though the numbers of young married men with a child
or two being taken into the army and becoming casualty
figures were now becoming rather alarming. By late 1916,
increasing shortages of troops, caused by ever increasing
casualty lists, saw laws passed to press men into the
nation's service; conscription had come in. The war effort
was not yet desperate enough to warrant calling up reserved
occupations in order to defeat the Germans.
CHANGING TIMES:
April of 1916 would bring a surprise Harry hadn't bargained
for. He was 'transferred' out of the Leicesters, to the
Royal Defence Corps, a sort of WW1 version of the Home
Guard. He was now in the 156 Protection Company, RDC, with
its HQ at Donington Hall, up near the county boundary west
of Kegworth.
I think this transfer would have come as something of a
shock. To be debadged from your home county regiment, into
something seemingly a lot more mundane and commonplace, is
no small thing. He had spent over 4 years learning about
comradeship and loyalty, and building up a considerable
amount of regimental pride. All that was seemingly set
aside, and despite his soldierly yearnings, he was pushed
aside and downgraded to local militia.
The fact that I can say that, with some degree of certainty,
is because of 'the picture', the framed picture of himself
that hung over the sideboard from roughly this time until
his death in 1972. It is I believe a pencil drawing, done at
some expense, and framed at even more expense. This image
online does not do it justice, for it is huge, like a very
large portrait mirror that would hang over a fireplace, and
does not here show the large, partially gilded frame. The
image of Harry in the oval, in his khaki complete with
peaked cap, is surrounded at the four corners by
unmistakable images of empire. Coloured drawings of HM The
King, Lord Kitchener, plus a Field Marshall (probably Sir
John French) and an Admiral, (probably Admiral Jellico) all
bedecked in the crossed flags of the Union Flag and the
Royal Standard. Was this Patriotic, or what? I have that
picture now, a treasured possession, hence this photo of it.
I believe the picture was done not so long after joining the
TF. His cap badge is unmistakable as that of the Leicesters,
the 'Tigers' as they're colloquially known. The pride in
regiment, and himself, oozes down on the viewer, and so it
did in that little back room in Highfield Street. But in a
way, having that picture done as it was, at that time,
whoever commissioned or paid for it, was that a little bit
of his undoing later. But that is some way into the future.
Harry's transfer to the RDC came right at the end of April,
and the next entry underneath that is dated 1 Oct 1916. In
more faded but still readable ink, it states, "Remaining in
Class 'W' TF Reserves as long as is necessary to retrain him
in civil employment." So no sign of any call 'to the
colours' as yet then.
I'm pretty sure Harry never saw that, for a man would never
get to see his own record, written up from all sorts of
forms and despatches from his own battalion headquarters and
sent up to London to be entered onto his own growing folder
of sheets and forms.
That was one of the many jobs of every battalion adjutant
and his office, with his little army of clerks, writing and
typing up records and sending them on to the War Office to
be kept in perpetuity. In the civil world of industry today,
that part of the adjutant's office would be called 'Human
Resources'.
So, despite the disasters of 1916, the setbacks and losses
of The Somme, he was still not to be called. By that time,
the numbers of men from all districts of all towns and
cities lost, listed as killed or missing, were horrendous.
Typed up lists were sent almost daily to individual towns to
be posted on town hall or civic hall notice boards, where
after every major battle, crowds would push and shove to get
close enough to discover who were the latest neighbours and
friends that had lost boys at the front. Widows and bereaved
parents would have already had the dreaded, black-edged
telegram telling of their worst possible news.
Harry, out and about in Coalville when not working, as would
Violetta when out shopping, would be very aware of these
lists and felt those losses as keenly as anyone else. He
would have been familiar with the Coalville Times, their
local rag, as well as the Leicester Mercury, and their
endless lists of the even greater losses being suffered in
that city and county wide.
He would also have been aware of the civic pressures on men
to sign up and serve, and undoubtedly he would have had a
little badge to wear on his jacket collar to signify that he
had signed up, and shown willing, and therefore most
definitely would not be deserving of the dreaded white
feather. Because of his TF service, coming and going
from parades in uniform, he would have been well known as a
keen soldier, but many of those neighbours were also mining
families. I doubt he was ever at risk of being deemed
worthy of a white feather.
So it was locally, in a mining town, that so many men who
were of an age and fitnest to serve were being held back
that he would have been nothing unusual. A casual observer
in Coalville market place on a typical nice Saturday in 1916
may have been forgiven for doubting that there 'was a war
on' at all, the place would have been full of miners old and
young.
For Harry, the next thing we see in his documents are the
little typed letters and forms concerned with recalling him
from Class 'W' reserve and the mix-up over his address. We
entirely miss out 1917, during which of course, the war and
its figures simply go from bad to worse, in every aspect, on
land and at sea. And by now, in the air too. The war was
more bogged down than ever, the front line hardly ever moved
and when it did it was at great cost in lives whether going
forward or back.
So I do have some suspicion now whether Harry was quite as
keen on soldiering by Christmas of 1917 as he had formerly
been as a teenager and then newly married man. He must
surely have been in a cleft stick, between a rock and a hard
place. Torn between duty to his country, to his regiment,
and duty to his wife and daughter, he would have reflected
on yet another major impending change in his circumstances,
of yet another baby.
Violetta would be in the end stages of her second pregnancy,
to Edna May, born at the end of January in the new year of
1918, and her birth given some pause for thought. Harry may
well have come to the view that whatever happened now,
however badly the war went, he would be going nowhere. But
events were conspiring against him, or for him, depending on
what view we take of his overall feelings at the time. We
can only surmise.
1918 came in, with a country totally despondant about the
course and state of the war. Whilst defeat was still largely
unthinkable to many, few seemed to think that it was a
winnable war either. A growing number had come round to the
view that the best we could hope for was a truce, some sort
of unpalatable settlement that would at least halt the
killing. Rationing had come in the previous year, we'd had
conscription since the year before that, and ever more young
men were called to the colours as they came of age to serve,
many of whose names would shortly appear on those casualty
lists. Through it all, Harry continued mining.
MOBILISATION :
Now we arrive at some very significant dates, the first of
which is 21st March 1918. This is the day of the first of
three serious 'big pushes' by the Germans on the Western
Front. Serious enough to take more territory back from the
Allies in one go than ever before, some 12 miles in places,
as well as negate all the gains in territory, and losses in
men, that had happened to date.
They did eventually get to within 70 miles of Paris, close
enough to bring up several gigantic artillery pieces on a
railway that could throw a huge shell 80 miles. Indeed, when
Paris was shelled for a time, for several weeks, it seemed
as if we may well lose the war after all. Such views were
only reinforced by the fact that the same advances further
north brought the German army perilously close to the
Channel ports, of Dunkirk and Calais. It very nearly became
a 'rehearsal' for the very sort of advance that would
famously take place in those quarters some 21 years later.
As is the nature of these things, all these advances were
very costly in lives, our lives as well as German, and that
day was the start of a succession of events that made the
whole situation be couched in terms as per Wellington at
Waterloo - "it was a damned close run thing."
By the end of that week of the first push, matters were so
serious the government realised that a great number of
reinforcements were going to be needed in France if we were
even going to hold the Germans from further advances, let
alone turn the tables and win ground back. The expected
American divisions were still being formed and training, and
their help was some way off still. Urgent action was
required.
To that end, frantic orders went out to battalions in other
theatres, such as Salonika where we were fighting the
Bulgars, dubious allies of the Germans. In Egypt and
Palestine, whole battalions engaged in fighting the Turks,
the other main German ally, quickly embarked for the south
of France to be rushed by train across France and up to the
front.
In England, it was deemed so serious that the call went out
to call up to the colours all 'W' class reserves, even those
men previously thought to be indispensable in their civilian
work but who would now be most certainly required to fill
dead mens' shoes and plug some very serious gaps in the
line. First, Canadian regiments had come to the front in
1917, and now American battalions were appearing in ever
greater numbers, but not trained up enough or yet of any use
to thwart any further German advances. The hope had been
that more American divisions could be put into the line
before the Germans made a serious 'spring push'. The hope
was not fulfilled.
Everyone at home knew the Americans were coming, and no
doubt last-line reserves like Harry may have started to take
some comfort that they may not be required at the front
after all. But the Germans were also well aware that time
was running out for them, and they knew they had to make
their move before those divisions could arrive, or lose the
war.
The enemy attack that had started on the 21st had, a week
later on the 30th, been sufficiently consolidated to worry
the government enough to take such drastic action. History
books tell us now that the 30th was the day on which the
decision was made in Whitehall, to call up those last
reserves as well as bring any troops that could be spared
back from various parts of the empire and other theatres of
war. We really were in dire straights this time.
THE NORTHAMPTONSHIRES? NEVER !!
I never thought I'd see a document that so clearly ties in
with the dramatic events of that time, but there is one in
Harry's records. Referring to the date, 30 March, and the
official line and numerical reference of his original
mobilisation order that went out along with thousands of
others, it is also later stamped 12 April, presumably when
it was sent out again following the address mix-up.
The Royal Mail was nothing short of excellent in those days.
Letters bearing OHMS were always delivered the very next day
after posting. Assuming he received it on the 13th, Harry
seems to have had barely 6 days to inform his boss and get
his kit together. Also to get his train ticket, paid for
with the travel warrant enclosed, and say his goodbyes. He
was not going to France, not yet, he had some serious
training to do first. But his instructions also contained
bad news, for he was going to be transferred into another
regiment. After all his time with the Leicesters, and then
the Royal Defence Corps, he was now to transfer to the
Northamptonshire Regiment to do his fighting, and not be
with his mates and comrades at all. It was akin to asking a
man in a Yorkshire regiment to go to Lancaster and join the
Lancashires. The ignominy of it all.
So this really is his call to arms, finally, his 'papers'
had arrived, instructing him to report to regimental
battalion headquarters, in Northampton, for a medical in
less than a week's time, on 19 April. This was the letter
that had previously gone astray by being sent to a
non-existant address, and the authorities had finally caught
up with him.
Whatever his thoughts were, we've no idea. Having begun to
think he may yet be spared, he was now faced with the only
option open to him, to go and do his duty. It was what he
had once wanted, what he had trained to do. And now he was
needed, so badly needed, and it was his turn to go, to leave
his wife and two daughters, of 2˝ years and new born, and to
fight as he had been trained to do. As he prepared himself
and girded his loins to whatever horrors were to come, the
news from France simply got worse and worse.
We have to assume that, medical over, he did go home for a
time, though his papers don't indicate that. The next date
we have is 14 May 1918, the date of his official transfer
into the Northants, and the 3rd (Reserve) Battalion.
A day or so before he set off on his journey for his
medical, on 19th April, the Germans made yet another big
push, further to the south this time, and this was the one
that actually enabled the shelling of Paris. The news of yet
another major offensive would have hit the papers before he
set off. As it happened, serious as it was, it was not of
the scale and magnitude of the March offensive, but serious
nonetheless.
History tells us now that the enemy really were running out
of steam, both in men and materials, and in enough troops
still willing to fight. As well as our naval blockade really
beginning to bite, the collapse of the Eastern Front the
previous year theoretically should have released enough men
to make any German big pushes in the west a more assured
success. Had they been fit and willing troops for their
kaiser, it may well have been.
But German troops returning from Russia, where many had been
prisoners-of-war, had been 'indoctrinated' by their captors
in new Red Army of Lenin, and many of them never made it to
the Western Front at all, they literally deserted in their
thousands. A good many who did arrive at their new units in
the west arrived drunk. We have something to thank the
Bolsheviks for.
So each of those further two 'big pushes' were of less
potency than the first, and each ran out of steam just as
quickly.
His service record appears to suggest that Harry had been
'stood down' from parades or attendances at the RDC for
quite a while beforehand, perhaps on account of his mining
activities. I do recall reading that miners, in the First
War as in the Second, were not required to do Home Guard or
any firewatching duties, or any civil defence duties outside
of their normal mining shifts. Those shifts were deemed to
be hard enough without depriving men of much-needed sleep
and affecting badly needed output.
For curiously, his record has had an extra bit of filling
in, as an afterthought, dated after some later entries, that
states he 'rejoined' the 156 Protection Coy, RDC, on 13 May,
only to be transferred into the Northants the very next day.
He had to be 'in something' to be transferred out of it, an
administrative quirk to keep army records straight. The
inference has to be that he had been excused parades and RDC
duties for some time before.
Harry's instructions are then to report to the 3rd Battalion
to commence his further training, his service with the
Northants officially starting on 14 May. This was presumably
at battalion HQ in Northampton, where several hundred men
would be on garrison duties, involved in training recruits
and transfers and running the behind-the-scenes aspects of a
regiment at war. Harry was also re-numbered at this same
time, now becoming Pte Holt, 204379. By now there were 7
such Northants battalions, three of them on the Western
Front, and one still in the Middle East. Just a couple of
weeks after he started his training, yet another major
attack occurred in France, the third for three months in a
row.
We know this now to be the Germans' final gasp, on 26 May,
their last throw of the dice. It was expected, and in high
command quarters, almost welcomed, as it signalled the end
of the German army as a credible fighting force that could
win the war. A strategic victory to them in the short term,
it became a tactical loss in that it did ultimately end any
hopes of any further big pushes. They were spent.
Heavy merchant losses at sea to submarine attacks still
meant that we could lose the war, not by defeat of our
troops on land, but by starvation at home. Things were
critical, and the fear was we would have to sue for peace,
come to terms with the enemy, abandon both the French and
the Belgians, and withdraw our armies from France. Defeat,
on terms that the Germans would dictate.
Like the two previous offences, successful as they were in
taking territory and inflicting heavy casualties, this last
attack also petered out, ran out of steam and energy and for
many different reasons. Notably the length of supply lines,
but also because German soldiers were over-running
previously unoccupied areas and coming across country houses
and chateaux with wine cellars stacked to the very brim.
Undisciplined and in a euphoria of successful bloodlust, so
many German troops quickly became drunk, and as well as
other factors, that became one of the significant reasons
for all three final offensives failing. From then on, very
slowly at first, the tables would turn, and through the
summer whilst Harry learnt a new trade and got to grips with
a new regiment, a new weapon, and new mates plus all that
went with it, the tide of war really did start to turn in
our favour.
Harry's new trade may not have been his choice. He may well
have had it foisted on him, as a 'needs must' situation.
Presumably he was a good shot with a rifle, and also
presumably because his record tells us no differently, he
was an able and disciplined soldier. For he now trained as a
Lewis gunner, thereby earning a few coppers more per day
than the ordinary infantryman. But it was a deadly trade,
and just as our infantrymen and artillery actively sought
out German machine gun posts, so did the Germans to ours.
From now on, he was effectively a more of a 'marked man'
than he had previously been.
Because he was no longer an infantryman in the basic sense,
he was now also part of a relatively new team in modern
warfare, usually of five or seven men.
Previous machine guns were very heavy pieces of kit, mounted
on a tripod, just as heavy. They required a team to carry
gun, tripod, ammunition boxes and all the other
paraphernalia and be able to move and change positions
during the course of a battle. The Lewis gun, designed in
America but produced in huge numbers in Britain by the end
of the war, would now be Harry's main weapon. It would also
mean there would be no 'on the whistle over-the-top' deadly
charges towards a stream of enemy machine gun fire. For now
Harry was part of the team on our side covering our troops
as they went over the top and he would be directing such
deadly fire directly at German defenders, hopefully seeking
out their machine gun nests in order to neutralise them.
The skills and requirements, the fine arts of operating and
using a lethal machine gun, had been taught us by the
Germans themselves. They started the war with a great many
machine gun companies within their regiments. Our massive
casualty figures in those first years, through the
offensives on The Somme, and later at Ypres and
Paschendaele, were our instruction on how to kill large
numbers of men in the shortest time with maximum effect.
We were so slow to learn, most of our county regiments could
only muster but two such machine guns in any one battalion
at the start of the war.
In those early days, our weapons were also much inferior to
the very highly engineered, lethal weaponry then coming out
of German arms factories, of the likes of Krupp, etc. It
took us some time to design and produce in large numbers
designs that could be of their equal. The Lewis gun was the
best known and most successful of those designs in use by
the Allies.
By the time Harry was doing his training four years later,
most battalions had dozens of these newer Lewis guns, plus
we had our own Machine Gun Corps that specialised in this
new art of mass killing. A line of Lewis gun teams
interspersed along the front every couple of hundred yards
was now seen as de rigueur, and an essential part of any
battle plan, both for offensive and for defence. It's what
the enemy had been doing for 4 years, and we paid a very
heavy price learning those lessons.
To this
new arm, this deadly weapon that some believed had been
devised by the devil, Harry Holt now sought to learn it's
deadly ways and give of his best.
Through that summer, in general, the news from the front did
now improve. The expected American divisions slowly did
arrive. Canadian regiments were already in the thick
of it and giving massive support to the exhausted British
regiments holding what was a very thin line in places. The
French seemed to find new heart, and many changes had taken
place in how we, the allies, prosecuted the war. No longer
sending men to die in their hundreds to defend the
indefensible, we were getting canny, and learning a sort of
warfare that would be recognised today.
Those three German offensives petered out because we now
made tactical withdrawals to allow the enemy to get ahead of
himself, and run out of reinforcements and supplies. We gave
ground to give him enough rope to tactically hang himself,
and saved lives in so doing. We abandoned the dubious merits
of defending a trench to the last man. There had also been a
big change in the High Command, and not just American and
Canadians, but Australians and Indians too all gained
something of a reputation for fighting like tigers.
The two main big differences between the log-jam war of the
previous two years and now were the increasing use of
camouflage, and the movement of reinforcements up to the
front lines and forward areas only by night. Troops were
forbidden to move by day, and instructed to keep concealed
in woods and hedgerows, to deceive the increasing observancy
activity of the German air force. When we made a big attack,
the enemy now did not see it coming, whereas most of all
previous attacks, by both sides, the element of surprise was
given away by good intelligence gathering and observing
daytime troop movements.
As the summer wore on, Harry was presumably now at Aldershot
or Warley, huge training areas down south. A great number of
regiments passed through those garrison towns, and others
like Warminster and towns close to Salisbury Plain. July
turned to August, exactly 100 years ago as I first wrote up
this account, and August to September. But to backtrack
slightly, a major event was developing that in itself very
nearly cost us the war, though it had little to do with the
war itself. But it just may well have saved Harry's life.
June had seen the first UK outbreak of Spanish Flu. Slowly
taking hold, it progressed through more and more of the
civilian population, killing hundreds as it went. It was a
curious strain of flu, in that it did not so much take off
the very young or elderly, it struck at those most fit,
generally in a teenager to mid-30s bracket. Some seriously
fit and notable sportsmen, many serving in various regiments
would go down with flu one day, and be dead within another
two. It was all too common for several folks in one house to
die almost together, like an attack of the plague.
It hit the army hard, very hard, but it hit the navy even
harder. By August, the Admiralty reported several instances
of Channel Fleet destroyers not being able to put to sea as
convoy escorts simply because so many of their crews were
struck down. Several merchant ship losses were ascribed to
this temporary affliction within the fleet and lack of
protection against U-boats.
The disease spread, not only across this country, but right
across Europe, and by mid-summer, the War Office would
report to the prime minister that some parts of the front
line were so stricken by this sickness that the line was
held very thinly indeed. The fear was that if the Germans
could have mounted just one more concerted attack in force,
they would have broken through once and for all, especially
if that breakthrough was towards the channel ports, always
their intention for four years anyway. But, the flu struck
them as well, even harder, on account of the by now very
poor nutrition of their troops. It would turn out that the
enemy had spent their last and best efforts in May. But of
course, our forces didn't know that then.
September would see Harry and his new mates guessing that
their period of training, just less than 5 months, was
coming to an end, and it would soon be time to go to it.
When his time came, events must have seemed to take on a
life of their own, and as is the way with army life after
months of training and a certain amount of boredom, things
start to happen in a bit of a rush, almost a whirl.
The first thing was his transfer to the 6th Battalion,
officially on 23 September, a nominal transfer only because
at that time, the 6th had been fighting in France since the
previous year and still were. They had sustained enormous
losses already and fought their way through many of the
notable battles that later became bywords of bravery and
endurance in British history.
After each action, all battalions would replace their losses
once they were relieved at the front with a supply of new
and fresh drafts of men sent from the two Infantry Base
Depots at Calais or Étaples, both near to the French coast.
Some men would be returning from sickness and wound
recuperation, and others would be raw new recruits, barely
18 years old and fresh out of training.
A cross-channel military ferry service, guarded by
destroyers of the fleet, maintained a constant to-ing and
fro-ing, bringing reinforcements to France and taking sick
and wounded back. In those final days of 1918, from the
summer onwards, the amount of that traffic and sheer numbers
of men became almost frenetic, an organised chaos. It is now
a known fact, not realised then quite so readily, though
many in high places would have suspected it, that we lost
more men killed and wounded in 1918 than in either of the
previous two years of the war. Notwithstanding those huge
losses at the famous actions on The Somme and at Ypres,
Cambrai, Amiens and others, the combined totals for the
smaller actions in 1918 alone would exceed them.
The three big final German spring pushes had accounted for
much of it, but now, with the Germans starting to be on the
run, and the flu taking its toll making manning matters much
worse and so yet even more casualties in battle as a result,
the figures were truly nothing short of horrendous.
What is notable is the number of older men amongst them,
those well over 30, sometimes up to their late 40s, married
men with several kids, who were sent to fight in those final
months when desperate measures required desperate means and
who did their duty but still succumbed to bullet or shell,
if not the flu.
TO FRANCE - AT LAST !
It is 24 September that sees Harry move closer to France.
First at another Northants transit and training camp on the
Isle of Sheppey, known as Scrapgate Camp, where his medical
the previous day unsurprisingly pronounces him 'A1 Fit' for
service abroad. From where he then travels to Dover to
embark, along with many other men also being posted to the
front, on a ship to France. He lands at Calais the very same
day, to find himself in no time aboard transport, perhaps a
lorry or train, en route to the IBD, the infamous Infantry
Base Depot, at Étaples, some 32 miles to the south, arriving
by that same night.
He had arrived. Harry was in France. After almost four years
of waiting, and reflecting that at one time, he had really
wanted this, he must have spent his first night feeling very
lonely and distant in this gigantic camp of tents and wooden
huts. Essentially a transit camp, an IBD is a human
distribution centre for want of a better description,
designed to hold men awaiting instructions for further
postings. This is where they were billeted in huge barrack
blocks, so slept, fed and watered and re-equipped whilst
they were allocated to a regiment, or awaited transport to
one they were already posted to. The 24th is also the
official day he becomes part of the 6th Battalion, but still
Harry is still a long way from it. He is re-badged, with a
new cap badge, displaying the triple castle turrets and
battle honour legend above, 'Gibraltar', of the
Northamptonshire Regiment.
The next entry, 29 September, he finally joins his regiment,
his unit, 'in the field'. This suggests he spent at least 3
or 4 days kicking his heels, along with other reinforcements
bound for the same destination. He would have no idea where
he was going, and I doubt at that time he knew the names of
very many French places, other than Paris and the famous
channel ports he had just passed through. Some names on the
Western Front had gained fame through newspaper reports. If
he had been keeping up with those, he may have noted the
name Saint-Quentin amongst all the others like Bapaume, and
Cambrai, famous for its recent tank battle.
News may have come through on the ubiquitous grapevine about
a huge action at Saint-Quentin, of a famous battle to cross
the wide canal there against massive German opposition, but
he may not have known then that was the site of one of the
6th Northants' most recent actions. He would a day or so
later when he finally caught up with them, at a little
village called Nurlu, well behind the then front line.
In actual fact, what I believe he caught up with were the
'battalion extras', at Nurlu, as stated in the recently
discovered battalion diary. For as the diary also makes
clear, the main body of the battalion itself was still in
action, to the north and east, and involved in some very
heavy fighting as they chased the Germans further and
further back and were not relieved for another couple of
days.
Something I hadn't realised until doing the most recent
research was that, when a battalion went into action, or up
to the front lines, they usually left behind the 'battalion
extras', which was a cadré of a few dozen officers and men,
experienced NCOs, and some admin staff, at a safe place
behind the lines. These were intended to rebuild the
battalion in the case of such severe casualties it had been
effectively wiped out.
This happened in very many cases, for there are dozens of
instances of so few men returning from an action that a
whole battalion of some 800 to a 1,000 men, effectively
ceased to exist. Hundreds may take part in an advance from
which barely small dozens would return. In such cases, they
may be merged with another badly mauled battalion, and it
was the job of the 'extras' to arrange for reinforcements,
order replacement equipment and munitions, and train the new
men for their new duties and rebuild damaged battalions.
It could take three weeks to a month for such a depleted
battalion to be rebuilt to a strength and ability enough to
go back into the line. I believe that Harry arrived at such
a time, when the battalion was about to be relieved and
return the the rear areas to rest and re-equip, and to
receive more men, such as Harry.
At 4am on the 29th, when Harry was probably travelling east
to Nurlu, the battalion was actually forming up on a start
line to go into action again about 5 miles to the east, very
near to Lempire and a farm noted in the diary as TOMBOYS
farm - an English spelling, as it is actually Le Tombois.
The farm is still there.
At 5.30, the battalion advanced 'behind Americans', the
diary says, with A and D Companies in the front line, and B
and C in reserve. They advanced slowly north-east all that
and the next day across the fields for a mile or so, to just
south-west of Vendhuile, taking yet some more casualties.
The diary talks of confusion caused by a 'smoke barrage' -
ours or the Germans, we don't know - and mentions 8 officers
wounded, including the company commanders of B and D
companies.
Brigade instructions had been to cross the canal at
Vendhuile, but fierce enemy machine gun fire had forced that
order to be abandoned, and the battalion dug in just west of
the town, but taking command of one of the canal bridges.
The fighting died down overnight, presumably because the
Germans did as they were always doing by now, packing up
their kit and legging it off into the night. It was here,
the next morning, they were 'relieved by the E. Surreys
after a very strenuous period'.
It was now October 1st, and the battalion then marched a
couple of miles to the west, back to some old trenches at
Ronnsay Wood, scene of a ferocious action only a few days
previously. Here they rested and regrouped, and it is here
that I believe Harry - along with other reinforcements -
most likely joined his new unit properly, literally 'in the
field'.
It is not too much a stretch of imagination to see them form
up into twos and march eastwards out of the camp at Nurlu
but four miles or so along the remains of country lanes,
such as they were by then, and by way of a couple of other
villages to join the main body resting at Ronnsay. From
herein, Harry's war started in earnest, and he would have
been forgiven for thinking that it was going to be a long,
long time before he saw the English Channel again.
We have to remember that, at that point, on October 1st
1918, a great many folk thought the war still long from
over. It was assumed by most that the Germans would have to
be chased, yard by yard, mile by mile, right back into their
own homeland before they would ever give it up and admit
defeat. Some in higher positions, a lot of senior officers,
sensed that an end was coming, but few would have put bets
on it being so close, and certainly not before Christmas.
Most soldiers in the line still believed it would be well
into 1919 before victory could be claimed. And of course, no
one knew just how it would end, with yet more massive
do-or-die battles, or a near stalemate, an outright victory,
or what. As close as we seemed to be to victory on the
Western Front, losses at sea could still decide the war in
the enemy's favour, and it would be they who would dictate
the terms. The balance was so fine.
But it was not to be immediate action for Harry. The
battalion had come out of the line, and would now get
transported, on presumably open backed lorries, though the
diary poetically terms it 'embussed', to take them many
miles to the west, well back from the present front line to
even better billets just north-east of Amiens, at
Molliens-au-Bois.
Perhaps they did use buses, primitive French-style
charabancs as well as lorries. They went back almost
directly west, traversing all the old battlefields and
criss-crossing many old front lines. That journey in itself,
to a very attentive newcomer to the war, would have been an
eye-opener indeed, a sort of impromtu live 'battlefield
tour'.
The fronts were still not all that far away, and the rumble
of distant artillery gunfire would occasionally be heard. At
night, the skyline to the north and east would be alight
with flares and occasional explosions of shells in the far
distance.
But though they were still well to the north of the old
battlefields of the Somme itself, it was a dispiriting
journey west through wrecked villages, along badly
shell-pocked lanes with barely any green or fresh growth of
anything to be seen. What could be seen would be heaps of
turned earth, littered with the remains of rusting barbed
wire, abandoned guns and kit, occasionally a wrecked newly
fangled tank, as they passed columns of troops marching the
other way to the front and units of military police at every
road junction directing traffic. Despite increasing
mechanisation, still to be seen would be an enormous number
of horses, mostly pulling supply and ammunition carts, and
of course, field guns of every size.
It was some 40 miles of unbridled destruction, the most
notable of which he almost certainly passed through was the
totally destroyed town of Albert. Hardly a brick or stone
left standing one above the other.
On arriving at Molliens-au-Bois, a camp of considerable more
comfort than had been enjoyed of late, though apparently
Nurlu wasn't so bad, Harry spent the next 14 days. He was
technically all ready and fit for battle, but his new
comrades newly returned from the fight now rested, bathed,
replaced lost or damaged kit, and generally relaxed. Harry
would have quickly been introduced to his gun team, or what
was left of them after their recent action. He would have
then heard his first real tales of battle, not third-hand or
hearsay from a long way away, or read in newspapers, but
first hand accounts by the men who were there.
The diary tells of a period of intense training to start
with, re-equipping, plus battalion inspections by the
Commanding Officer. The 6 October was a Sunday, and a
planned church parade was cancelled owing to no chaplain
being available. No doubt there were times they were also in
short supply, and doing more gruesome duties elsewhere.
From the 10th, there were many more lighter moments in camp,
notably inter-regimental and inter-divisional football
matches. On that day, 6/Northants drew two-all with the
11/Royal Fusiliers. The next day, they lost 4-0 to the
2/Bedfordshires.
The 12th is almost lighthearted, a Brigade Sports Day, and
Lt-Col. Turner in writing up the diary - our bits are all in
his scrawling hand throughout - he writes, 'Joy Day.'
We can only speculate and wonder in how much of this Harry
took part. It would have seemed odd to have come so far to
end up playing sports and football. The 13th may have been
even more joyous; this time, there was both a church parade
and a major inspection by the GOC Brigade. Followed by yet
another match, a return game against the 11/Royal Fusiliers,
and this time they thrashed them 5-1. Oh what joy!
But underlining all that 'joy', all troops would have known
they were only preparing and girding themselves to be sent
back into the fight. Including Harry. Just another couple of
days now. There was serious work to be done.
"ADMIN INFLUE" :
On the 15th, the battalion received instruction on
'Protection on The March', and 'Outpost Duty'. The following
day, transport arrived, and the whole battalion 'bussed it'
back to Nurlu, a first move back in the direction of the
fighting to relieve another battalion, and so the cycle
began all over again. In and out of the line, as the
6/Northants had been for much of the war, frequently with
many men just as fresh to battle as Harry now was.
But not Harry. It is my belief he perhaps began to feel ill
even on the 14th, when on the final day of the Brigade
Football competition, they got their revenge and beat the
2/Bedfords 1-nil. I do wonder if Harry was already very
off-colour by then.
For on the 15th, his own records state: 'To Hospital', and
place given, 'in the field'. The next entry is the same day,
also on the 15th, to 54th Field Ambulance, 'Admin Influe'.
Harry was out of it, and to date, had never fired a shot,
not in anger anyway. And it was now looking as if he never
would.
So it would be Spanish Flu that saved him from going with
the battalion the next day as they went back to the front,
and perhaps even worse, we'll never know.
As the battalion shipped out one way, Harry was almost
certainly on a stretcher in a covered ambulance going the
other. This time to the 41st Stationery Hospital at Amiens,
which in fact was the former big town civilian hospital and
so far as I know, still is.
Eight days there saw a good deal of recovery. He was indeed
a very lucky man. Some battalions had a higher death rate
than others, it was never universal. To make an average,
which is meaningless really, some battalions hardly lost a
man, others had so many afflicted they were effectively of
no use for several weeks, with a death rate worse than that
in battle at that time. Significantly, Harry's Northants
battalion appear to make no mention of this epidemic in the
war diary. First impression has to be they didn't have that
many.
However bad he had it, and however soon they caught it, it
was Amiens that saved him and started to put him to rights.
The next move was to the coast, to Le Tréport, to the 16th
General Hospital, where he spent about a fortnight. He must
surely now have been on the road to recovery and felt a good
deal better. That flu either took you quick, or not at all,
but recovery was a long time.
His final move was to the 3rd Canadian Hospital, then at
Dannes-Camiers, again not far from the coast. All these
military hospitals can be researched and appear on various
WW1 websites, but care must be taken to note the dates, as
they moved around considerably, but they are now all
'findable' online. They may be designated 'Stationary'
hospitals, but they were anything but that. No41 quoted
above was in five different places during the course of the
war, finally ending up in Germany for the occupation.
The move from Le Tréport to Dannes-Camiers was at least in
the right direction, from the army's point of view, as it
was clear they wanted him back. Due west across the channel
may have been Harry's preferred direction, but it was not to
be. The 3/Canadian Hospital was just north of the IBD at
Étaples, and it is to there that he was sent on 8 November.
He remained there until the 15th November, so there we have
it. Armistice Day, the end of it all, would be spent in
contemplation if not celebration, in a Canadian-staffed
hospital miles from the front, and miles from home.
Contemplating his luck, or lack of it, for he had never
fired a shot in anger.
For many, celebration was too strong a word, especially
those still 'in theatre', those in the battlefields, whether
soldiers, admin, medics or whatever. There were joyous
celebrations at home, often deliriously so and well OTT, but
many celebrations were still rather muted when folks paused
and remembered the huge cost of this dubious victory. I
think whether one celebrated or not was directly linked to
how many of your own family had been lost in the carnage.
Some men at home celebrated because it almost certainly
removed the immediate possibility of call-up, or at least of
being shot at. But it was not all fun and games for
everyone.
When he was first admitted to hospital in mid-October, even
then the end wasn't really thought to be quite so close.
Having come through the flu and starting to recover,
realising he had not died after all, Harry may even then
have hankered after getting back to his unit and fearing it
would all be over before he got there. Or maybe not. Maybe
he regarded it as God's blessing and could now be a little
more reassured he would be returning home to his family -
one day.
Because of his illness, at least two of three days of which
he would be almost in a coma, out of it, and then the
repeated moves from one hospital to the next, it would all
have seemed something of a whirlwind. As he recovered, and
heard the tragic tales of others that had not survived, deep
regrets and negative feelings almost certainly set in. He
was a quiet man in old age, contemplative, slow to anger,
but as my mum often recounted, when he was riled, everyone
knew about it. Slow volcanos often go off with the biggest
of bangs.
And now, with recovery, the whirlwind was not over. It was
back to the base depot to await transport to rejoin his
unit. Not fighting now, but heavily involved in what must
have been the biggest 'clear up' in history. He didn't kick
his heels long at IBD this time, a day or so, for on the
17th he was back across France at his Battalion rest centre.
The 19th saw him back 'in the field', after a second
journey, not a bit comfortable at a guess, back across the
war-torn battlefields.
And what a 'field' it must have been. The diary tells us,
after nearly a fortnight's final heavy fighting up to the
11th, the 6/Northants ended up near Le Cateau, not so very
far from Ronnsay Wood and Epephy close to where he'd joined
them the first time. Back on the 4th and 5th November, they
went through a particularly bad time, in the actions at
Eppinette Farm. Three officers were wounded, 15 other ranks
were killed and 96 wounded, and one man was posted missing
entirely.
So close to the very end, men were still being lost in some
numbers. But, even on the 5th, although there was much talk
that it was nearly all over, as the grapevine and rumour
mill abounded with stories that German commanders had met
with French and British to seek terms, there was still no
confirmation at battalion levels.
Harry rejoined 6/Northants on 17 November, to what must have
been a very different atmosphere. A mixture of huge relief,
almost shock, perhaps even disbelief, as well as a sort of
childish euphoria still remaining amongst many. Now, there
was a lot of work to be done, but at least it wasn't
killing. Or being killed. Most of that initial euphoria at
such an unexpected victory would by now have passed amongst
most fighting men still out there. The biggest and most oft
asked question on most soldiers' lips was -'when are we
going home?'. For some, quite soon, but for now, there was
work to be done, some serious 'tidying up', a great deal of
it not at all pleasant and very likely to leave a sensitive
man with nightmares years later.
The diary is now very bland and matter of fact for the next
month or so, telling of the battalion involved in filling
trenches and shell holes around their villages, a great deal
of salvage work which covers everything from gathering up
masses of barbed wire to shell and cartridge cases by the
ton, to removing what was now scrap metal in all its forms,
damaged and wrecked guns, limbers, carts and all the
material of an army in the field. Diary entries don't
specify what 'salvage work' and clearing up entailed in
detail, but there can be no doubt that it would have
frequently been a most gruesome task. One job noted was to
'remove all evidence of German occupation' for the
villagers. I'd like to think our lads were very welcome, and
treated like the gentlemen they very much were, as well as
liberators.
Another task that befell some was the re-burying of the
dead, finding the more recent hurried graves on the
battlefield, and exhuming the bodies to be taken to the
larger cemeteries then just starting to be created.
Such work had to be very heavily documented as they
progressed, no detail missed, every man recorded where
known, and what details as could be ascertained via cap and
shoulder badges where the name wasn't known. German as
well as British or Allies, every dead man had to be recorded
and typed records sent back to London, or liaised with their
former enemies in the German army. I think Harry may
well have escaped the worst of that too, but he would have
known, heard, just what strong stomachs it took to exhume
and rebury so many dismembered and rotting corpses.
The next more interesting entries are mid-December, when
Lt-Col Turner's handwritten account seems to take on a more
visibly cheerful note. His handwriting gets a bit larger and
more floral, as he tells of preparations of billets and
recreation rooms within camp for the looming Christmas
period. There are church parades, and inspections, and I
daresay men chafed at that, but an army is an army, and
needs to keep fit and sharp and on the ball. There was
always the danger the armistice might fail, and some more
hard-lined German commanders may gather enough troops for it
to all kick off again. The 6/Northants were lucky in that
they stayed roughly where they were when hostilities ceased,
in the Walincourt, Malincourt and Élincourt area. These were
the main focus of daily work parties to clean up the
villages and help the inhabitants in their first steps along
a long road to some sort of normality.
December 23 is marked as a 'start of the Christmas holiday',
and undoubtedly there would be a great clammering for leave,
but not always granted. I'd like to think that Harry had
some sort of a clue as to his early demob when he returned
from his sickness the month before and may even have
entertained hopes of being home for Christmas.
The first he may have heard, could have been on the 17th
when he got back to the battalion and perhaps wondering what
he had to do next. History books tell us now that our High
Command had indeed some considerable prior knowledge that
the end was near. For several weeks, intelligence reports
were telling that the German army was so near to collapse
that it seemed unlikely they could fight on even until the
end of the year. Enemy generals had been making moves since
mid-October to ask for terms to end it. Given that
knowledge, preparations had been in hand for some time to
arrange for coal miners to be returned just as soon as the
last shot was fired. But of course, neither Harry nor any of
his mates were aware of any of that at the time. On the day
that Harry got back, some sarcy NCO might well have turned
round and said, "you're going to be alright, Holt, you lucky
sod, you're going home! Miners are being returned first."
HOME ?
And indeed they were, and the guns had barely fell silent
before the first of those orders were being sent from London
to brigades and battalions everywhere. The pits at home were
in a real crisis, the winter hard, and folks were literally
freezing for want of coal. And of course, the shortages were
hitting industry badly too.
But many of the demob instructions were not popular, neither
with the men nor some of their officers. There was a great
deal of disquiet in a lot of divisions, and almost mutiny in
a few. After miners, the next main group were described as
'pivotal men', which encompassed every sort of trade and
skill that had been robbed mercilessly to provide troops to
fight the war. Naturally, the men that had volunteered
first, before the days of conscription in 1916, expected to
demob first, but in many cases it didn't work out that way.
I sense that Harry, envied and considered lucky by his
messmates, may have attracted not a little jealous sarcasm
in his last weeks of service.
We know nothing of how he spent Christmas, but it was not at
home. He was now a member of 'A' Company, and the diary
tells that B and D companies had their Christmas dinner,
served by officers, at 1300hrs on the 25th. A and C
companies had to wait for theirs until Boxing Day. If he
didn't know already as he had his dinner, he would have done
the next day for sure. His records state that on the 29th,
he was 'transferred to England for release from the army for
coal mining.'
It seems he was back in England for New Year's Day, but not
yet in the bosom of his family. His soldier's Protection
Certificate and Certificate of Identity (for soldiers not
remaining with the colours) is dated Jan 5th at Talavera
Barracks at Aldershot. His place of rejoining in an
emergency is given as Purfleet, and trade as L.G.
His record, and that certificate, shows he was given 28 days
leave, and officially left the colours on 2 Feb 1919. But I
think he was finally home by the 6th Jan, and back at work
easily within a few days. When he entered the lift cage to
go underground for the first time in almost a year, he must
have pinched himself and thought, did I do all that.
He was still regarded as a soldier, only being released to
Class 'W' Reserve, and Lt-Col Turner has signed the official
form, 'Release from the army for coal mining (overseas)'. So
England was 'overseas', was it. Very good, no matter.
I felt a bit sorry for Col Turner as I reached the end of
this narrative. He was obviously approaching elderly status,
if not already 60 then not far off, looking at photos of him
in the archives with his big bushy, white mousetache. He had
taken a wound, from a shell, the previous year when in
command of the Royal Fusiliers, and earlier in 1918 had been
away from the battalion for a few months. He in fact
rejoined in September, just before Harry arrived. Turner
must have known, as would all elderly and long-overdue for
retirement officers would have known, that the end of the
war was the end of life as they knew it. Not every officer,
or man, so quickly retired, had the foggiest idea what they
were going to do with themselves. Not all had a career or
means of employment to support themselves if still aged
under 65. Life was very tough, for hundreds of
thousands of men of all ranks suddenly thrown to the
vagaries of the winds of civilian life.
In the event, Col Turner left before Harry did. The diary,
filled in by his own hand in scrawling pencil as usual,
states at date 2 Jan 1919 ... 'Lt-Col Turner left the
battalion.' And that was that. A major took charge for the
next couple of months until the 6th Battalion was finally
disbanded in April. They had gained some considerable battle
honours, been involved in endless heroic fights and suffered
huge numbers of casualties. Harry had joined them almost
right at the end, and had been spared the worst of the
horrors his predecessors had had to go through - by simply
having the flu.
I have no doubt that Harry was proud of his army service, as
witnessed by the continued presence of his picture hanging
on the wall above the sideboard until the day he died. I've
no doubt Violetta, and in time, his four daughters were
proud of him too. I can also state with some certainty that
he was a patriot, a loyal subject of his king, and didn't
subscribe to the later condemnations of Great War leaders,
like Haig and Lloyd-George, who were later belittled as mass
murderers.
How do we know. Purely from the graphics around his image,
images of the king and some of those war leaders. He would
not have left them there if he had agreed with such views,
and would surely have had the picture removed from its
patriotic, flag-bedecked mount even if it was then rehung
plainly in the living room.
CONCLUSIONS :
I'm also sure Harry was a socialist, with a relatively
small 's', and of course, a member of the miner's union.
There may seem to be some conflict, an anomoly, with all
those viewpoints. Moreover, he was very religious, of the
Methodist/Salvationist persuasion, and all the more so
after the war as he tried to come to terms with what
little he had seen of it. For some men, experiences of war
drives religion and faith clean out of them. For Harry, it
seems to have strengthened them, and perhaps an increasing
faith is what helped carry him through those dark days,
years later in the 1930s, when we know he had nervous
breakdowns and more than one stay at the miners'
convalescant home at Cromer. Life was a constant struggle,
even on miner's pay. It's what all the arguments and
strikes and constant strife with pit bosses and later
governments were all about.
Life was very tough through the 1920s by our cossetted
standards of today, and if a lot of men who returned from
the war had little or no political views when they went to
war, they certainly developed strong ones in the two
decades after. Two more daughters would be his and
Violetta's blessing, Mavis in 1923, and Sylvia my mum, a
full 7 years later in 1930. By the time Sylvia was born,
Gladys was 14 and already about to move away, to
Loughborough, 'in service' to a wealthy baker's family.
All of this story could never have been told as full as it
has been without first gaining access to Harry's service
record. Moreover, not only access, but being able to
understand it. Without that, all I had was the family
legend, which was that Harry had spent most of the war in
France, had been a long time in the trenches, and wounded
in the backside which was the source of not a little mirth
whenever it was mentioned. In fact, it was just about the
only reference to Harry's wartime service that I recall
ever being openly talked about. Indeed, in his records,
there is a 'Casualty Form' that makes mention of a wound,
unspecified, but dated before he went to France and
certainly before he caught the flu. The form makes it
clear that his next of kin had been notified of this, but
of what, it doesn't say. Given that, I suspect the legend
of the wound is true, but gained in training.
I should add that all family historians know that the
Great War service records are known as 'The Burnt
Records', because two-thirds of them were totally
destroyed in the Blitz during the Second War, and of the
third that did survive are so badly singed and burnt that
many are almost unreadable. But Harry's, they are almost
pristine, and by and large very clear indeed. I have been
very lucky. I see many other mens' records in my searches
on behalf of other people, and Harry's are some of the
clearest I've ever seen.
The picture, so well-known to the family thereafter,
seemed to reinforce the whole story such as we got it. No
one later seems to have questioned anything, and grandad
never really spoke about it. I never heard him make such
or indeed any claims, that he had been in the trenches,
but then, other than that odd joking reference to 'being
shot in the backside', none of it was ever discussed. It
seems that the picture, drawn so long before he went to
France, may have been some sort of hostage to fortune that
would forever taunt him. His later nervous breakdowns were
commonly put down by his daughters to the traumas of his
time in the trenches, shooting so many men dead, and
witnessing so many friends taken likewise. I can't fathom
it, but his service record is clear enough, and especially
now allied to the battalion diary - it didn't happen, not
quite like that, anyway. Not at all like that in fact.
Some years ago, puzzled by his now revealed record, and
sure I had read it wrong or that salient bits were
missing, I mentioned what I had found to my eldest aunt,
Gladys, who was a young girl in the 1920s and always
proudly believed her dad had served in France throughout.
Aunty was horrified at the suggestion he had not; it was a
slur, untrue, and she was visibly upset, for which I was
truly sorry. I went home and looked at the record sheets
again, searching for the missing clue that would say he
had been to France before September 1918, and my readings
were incorrect. She faithfully believed what she had grown
up to believe, right to being a 90 year old woman.
As did my mum, and both other aunties in their turn. They
had never seen any reason to believe otherwise. In fact,
going back and taking a closer and more studied reading of
all the sheets revealed more minor facts and details not
realised before, but they didn't alter one whit the facts
of the places and dates already mentioned. Harry was too
religious to tell an outright lie, he didn't fib, but yet
he had seemingly allowed the myth of his service to grow.
When I was growing up, and giving my own mum a hard time,
grandad would be held up as the apogee of duty and
service, a man who had faced four years of danger in the
trenches and always done his best.
There is another explanation. Harry didn't 'allow'
anything, for he just didn't realise what context was
being read into the portrait hanging on the wall. It is
perfectly plausible and possible that he had no idea of
what his daughters thought, or thought they knew, about
his war service, as they grew up. Fathers commonly
then did not discuss their war service with daughters, and
not all that often with sons.
So if they never discussed it, it could be the 'facts' I
had grown up with were his own daughters' mere assumptions
born out a genuine lack of real knowledge of the true
timetable of events. Of course, later on, he would have
his medals, and these would proudly state to any viewer
that he had taken part in the Great War. They would give
no clue as to how little that part had been, for he had
been in the 'France & Flanders' theatre of war for the
required amount of time to qualify for their award, even
if it was right at the very end. So he had 'Pip, Squeak
& Wilfred', amusingly nicknamed after famous cartoon
characters of the time, being the France & Germany
Star, the War Medal, and the Victory Medal. They seemed to
tell all that was needed to know.
In addition, there was yet another 'picture', which I have
also inherited. It is this nicely framed, coloured
certificate, from the Northamptonshire Territorial
Association, thanking H. Holt for his service during the
Great War of 1914-1919. Seeing that when growing up, what
else would a child think other than he had served for four
years.
And where had he served? Why, France of course! So there
we have it, a family myth and legend born out of silence.
Harry's reticence to talk about it, those pictures ever
present hanging in the house, plus knowledge of his
medals, would all conspire to build a myth of war service
that he himself may well not have even been aware such a
myth existed.
The fact that this certificate thanks him for serving with
the 4th Battalion, when it should have said the 6th, is of
no matter. I can find no mention of the 4th in his service
record, only the 3rd, which was the reserve battalion, and
then the 6th on going to France. But, hanging on the same
wall, not too far from his portrait, it would have served
to his daughters to add to a legend that didn't exist. We
also have to assume that Violetta wanted them displayed,
that she was proud of him and wanted to show that her
husband had served, whether Harry was comfortable with
them on show or not. Without any information to the
contrary, and with little or no information from Harry
himself, it could well be that it was Violetta herself
that unwittingly taught her daughters of their father's
long and glorious war service. Harry had gone off to the
war in May of 1918, and she may well have been totally
unaware that he had not reached France until late
September. It is perfectly reasonable to think that
Violetta had no idea that her soldier husband had arrived
so late at the fight that he had never fired a shot.
It's not as if there is any shame in Harry's true story.
He was keen enough, dutiful enough and showed not a hint
of unwillingness to serve or any suggestion of cold feet.
He served all four years in uniform of one unit or
another, itching to go and do his bit. He never 'dodged
any column'. Quite the contrary; when called, he went,
dutifully. He was not alone, in Coalville or any other
mining district. There would be many men he later went
down the pit with after the war, shared 'snap time' with,
who also were held back and finally only sent to the war
when it was about to come to an unexpected end and thus
too late to take part in anything meaningful. In that
sense, he would not have stood out. As I said right at the
beginning, he was ordinary, within the happenings and
occurrences of his time. There would be many like him, and
in other mining towns across the nation too.
I was not the oldest grandson. There were three others
before me, one who went on to serve in the RAF in the
1950s. I'm sure he spoke to his grandad about his Great
War years, and for all I know, maybe he did play it down a
bit and shrug off those youthful enquiries that a boy
makes to a grandfather known to have served. Again, that
picture reinforced everything. Was it that, against so
much expectation of daughters and younger members of the
family growing up, including some nephews, he just
couldn't bring himself to tell that he had in fact, got
there just a little too late.
Harry returned to his work at Ellistown Colliery Company,
and remained a miner for some years. But there were very
hard times ahead. Industrial strife, plus a failed attempt
to start a family shop. He and Violetta turned their
little front room, now numbered 208 Highfield Street, into
a shop, retailing the garden produce and veg he was so
good at growing. They had a horse, named Tommy, remembered
well by my aunties, and a cart. The horse was stabled down
Standard Hill, but there are stories of the fun to be had
when the horse used to come home, clip-clopping up the
entry and round the back to try to get into the house.
Even before my mum was born, in 1930, they remembered
going on Sunday trips 'over the forest' to Shepshed to see
grandma and grandad Manderfield, and recalling an occasion
going up a steep bank when they all slid out of the back
of the cart and onto the lane. But episodes of 'nervous
breakdowns' would see Harry go to the Miners' Welfare
Convalescant Home at Cromer more than once.
The grocery business failed . . . because they were too
soft, and gave too much credit and goods away. The General
Strike finished them, giving so much 'tic' to neighbours
and friends, they were effectively giving their produce
away. Ultimately, in years to come, Harry would have to
give up mining, with increasing back trouble. But he had
to have a job, no disability pension then, a man had to
work, or he and his family starved. He got a job on
Coalville tip, working for Coalville UDC. And I believe
that it was there that he found he had a skill mending
clocks. He found so many broken clocks and watches
discarded in bins, to ultimately be thrown onto the tip,
that he could always find new parts, balance springs,
glass, to mend those clocks of friends and neighbours.
I have memories of often seeing three or four mantle
clocks of various sizes, as well as wrist and pocket
watches, sitting on the sideboard under that picture, all
awaiting collection having been repaired or adjusted for
time-keeping. I also seem to recall a tanner a time (6d)
was the going rate for simple regulatory adjustment for a
clock running fast or slow. In the back room, there was
the usual built-in floor-to-ceiling cupboard in the recess
besides the fireplace, for crockery and domestic items. It
incorporated two large, deep drawers, with a brass
pull-handle, crammed almost to the rim with watch parts of
all sizes; clock faces, glasses, every type of spring and
sprocket wheel imaginable, with as many hands, winders and
all the other parts that made a timepiece.
My last memories, other than at my wedding, are of
watching this old soldier, now bent almost double and
crippled by a life of arduous hard work down the pit and
'on the dust', at the dining table and patiently
assembling or disassembling some clock he'd had to
pieces. His glasses on the end of his nose, a fine
screwdriver in hand and quietly sucking his teeth as he
quietly concentrated on the finer points of watch repair,
are almost my last memories of him at home.
Had it not been for the flu, he most definitely would have
seen some action, and quite possibly been wounded. The
battalion diary makes that very clear. Out of a battalion
of 800 or so men, roughly in four companies of 200 each,
we know that only two of those companies took part in that
last action of the 6/Northants, and they were merged
together because they were understrength from losses in
other more recent actions, such as Saint-Quentin and the
canal. So from a strength of some maybe 300 men in total,
nearly a hundred had taken wounds, and five were killed.
It's hard to draw the conclusion Harry really did have a
lucky escape there. Did he curse the day he got the flu,
in the deadliest epidemic in Europe since the plague, or
did he thank God for his deliverance from a veritable
hell.
None of us, now or in the future, will ever know. But I'm
thankful he did, and so would my mum have been had she
known all this. Shocked, true, but thankful on deeper
reflection.
Finally, it is a debatable point that, had Harry not been
taken ill with the flu, and thus gone with his 'A' Company
on what would become their last action ever in the war,
would he have survived to come home to his family. Or
morevover, survived but have been so wounded he would
never have any more family? Two more daughters and another
six grandsons are the direct result of his survival, of
both the war and the flu. One thing is for sure, his
wartime service influenced his four daughters greatly, and
by definition their children. The research has answered
many questions, but has opened up even more that can never
be answered. In history, perhaps that is how it should
always be.
text revised Nov 2021
|